Thursday, February 6, 2020

Synthesis Essay: A Snapshot of Native Identity



Indigenous. Native. Indian. American.

Contemporary Native American identity can be a tricky to navigate. As explored in Tommy Orange’s There There, many of today’s Native community struggle to rectify their identity with their culture's past. But how do these fictional accounts intersect with accounts of real-life Native Americans? What about their struggle is fictionalized and what is genuine? In a synthesis essay, bring together one main character from There There (e.g. Opal Viola Victoria Bear Shield) and at least three of the following articles. Find the common thread between all the texts so that a “snapshot” of contemporary Indian identity emerges.

Choose at least three of the following texts to synthesize with a character from There There.:

  1. “My Mother is Native American, but I Look White. My Identityis More than My DNA.” (Washington Post)
  2. “Who Decides Who Counts as Native American?” (New YorkTimes)
  3. “Native American is Not My Race—It's Who I Am” (Vice)
  4. “OpDocs: A Conversation with Native Americans on Race” (NewYork Times)
  5. “Indigenous Voices: Life as a Young and Native American”(Vice)

The best papers will:
  • Stay within the parameters of the prompt
  • Have a concise thesis illustrating the relationship between a There There character and real-life Native Americans
  • Find "common threads" among a diverse group of texts and combine them to create a "snapshot" of contemporary Native identity
  • Properly cite evidence using MLA's parenthetical citation method 
  • Conclude with a summation of your points
  • Be in MLA Style  

Required:
  • MLA Style
  • Approximately 750 words
  • Works cited 
Due: Fri 2.14

Monday, February 3, 2020

Reflection 2: Yours for the Taking?—On Cultural Appropriation

Cultural appropriation is the act of one culture "incorporating" aspects of another culture into its own. This differs from cultural exchanges in which American hip-hop and Bollywood-style dancing might incorporate each other's moves or Korean and Mexican cuisines sharing  ingredients and techniques. In cultural appropriation, a dominant group assimilates aspects of a foreign culture without regard to their original use or intent. In other words, parts of one culture might be absorbed into another in insensitive, even offensive, ways, often for their perceived cool factor. Thus, we've seen white hipsters embrace Mexico’s Dia de los Muertos, the popularization of sacred Maori symbols as tattoos, and the labeling of a clean, Asian-influenced interior design as Zen-style. Additionally, African-Americans have endured the absorption of their culture (cornrows, slang, etc.) for consumption in mainstream white culture, while American Indians are still routinely exoticized. Cultural appropriators often claim they are simply showing an appreciation for those cultures—“I’m actually honoring that culture.” But what’s the line between appreciating a culture and disrespecting it? What obligation, if any, do we have to educate ourselves first? For example, can we truly understand the traditions of Ojibwa dreamcatchers when they're worn as earrings, or respect Hindu and Buddhist principles when we do yoga with goats? Is it possible to appreciate another culture in a more respectful manner? How can that be achieved? For this reflection, examine the debate over cultural appreciation.


Include at least two of the following in your discussion:
Required:
  • MLA Style
  • Approximately 300 words
  • Works cited 

Due: Fri 2,7